Holiday rentals in Protestant Cay

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Protestant Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Apartment in Christiansted

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Views, location, comfort - This condo has it all!

Gorgeous top floor end unit with both mountain and harbor views in one of the best condo complexes on the island! Schooner Bay Condos are tucked away on a hillside overlooking Christiansted Harbor, the Marina, Fort Christiansted, and Protestant Cay - conveniently located to everything! Walk to the market, shops, parks, restaurants, and Downtown Christiansted and Boardwalk. PLEASE NOTE: This condo requires climbing lots of stairs to access. This unit is NOT for folks who have limited mobility.

Guest favourite

Flat in Christiansted

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Blackbeard's Rendezvous - Downtown Danish Villa

The Bonney, a gated historical Danish villa, rests in the heart of downtown Christiansted! Just 0.2 miles from the Christiansted Boardwalk and walking distance to the ferry, seaplane, shops, bars & restaurants, waterfront, national parks and historic sites. This beautiful 1-bed, 1-bath suite provides AC, WiFi, smart TVs, and a fully equipped kitchen. Access to snorkel gear, beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers, and all your beach needs! Enjoy everything St Croix has to offer in comfort and safety!

Guest favourite

Apartment in Christiansted

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Blissful Seas

Beautiful Caribbean Sea views from this lovely studio condo unit. Enjoy relaxing out on your own private balcony while enjoying cool breezes and beautiful sea views. Just steps to a white sandy beach adorned with cabanas. The unit has modern updates and amenities to make you feel right at home. Club St. Croix has a private pool, spa, tennis & pickle ball courts, and on-site restaurant. Just a few minutes drive to historic Christiansted for waterfront dining, shopping and daily excursions.

Guest favourite

Guest suite in Christiansted

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

The Llama: Unique Boho Caribbean Spot (2 of 3)

5 Star hospitality with a boho Caribbean feel! "The Llama" is one of 3 available rooms at this private Caribbean stand alone property. Rent one room for 2 guests, 2 rooms for 4, or rent all three for larger parties of 6! Grill out in the extremely private & lush courtyard as you kick back enjoying the local fruit trees. We are an affordable beautiful place to stay, but don't expect the Four Seasons if you have unrealistic expectations at this price point consider another higher end rental.

Guest favourite

Flat in Christiansted

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

The Welcome Sea View House

The Welcome Sea View House is located minutes from Pharmacy, SeaSide Gourmet Deli and Supermarket as well. Hotel on the Cay for swimming and relaxation! There is also Sharkey’s Restaurant for eating, music, and playing Pool! There’s also a Laundromat minutes away, a Tennis Court, and a playground! The Boardwalk for music, dining, and entertainment are located minutes away for your convenience! We are conveniently located minutes away from The QE IV Ferry and the seaplane are min. away!

Guest favourite

Flat in Christiansted

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Slice of Paradise

Hello visitors to St Croix! Quietly situated on a peaceful and private hillside overlooking the crystal clear waters of Christiansted, this island studio apartment features a queen-size bed, free unlimited WiFi, and remote-controlled air conditioning. Just minutes away from “downtown” where you'll find delicious dining, fantastic entertainment, and several local shops. Conveniently located near the QE IV Ferry and seaplane, should island hopping be part of your plan.

Guest favourite

Bungalow in Christiansted

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Sailor's Rest, a Romantic and Luxurious Sanctuary

The real luxury of Sailor's Rest stems from the exclusivity of its location. nestled into the hillside overlooking Salt River Bay, the views and the privacy are unparalleled. Only the pool is shared with me in the main house, but I always give my guests full use and privacy, so it will seem like it is yours alone. I understand how important your vacation is and will always go the extra mile to ensure your stay delivers the luxury and serenity you deserve.

Guest favourite

Flat in Christiansted

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Escape to the Island of St. Croix

Come stay in our 1-bedroom apartment in a great neighborhood. Ideal location for 5 minute drive to Downtown Christiansted Harbor where you can schedule boat tours to Buck Island, visit gift shops, restaurants and historic sites. Also, Frederiksted is a short drive to visit Rainbow Beach. The apartment is located at the end of the main house with your own private entrance. Fruit trees are all around the premises. Great for Business and Personal Getaways!

Guest favourite

Apartment in Christiansted

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Modern 1 Bedroom 0.7 Miles to Christiansted Board

Relax in a tropical island themed getaway pad with pops of colorful, retro and modern surprises. Soak up the sunrise with light pouring in from the large picture window, while you wait for your little pink breakfast station to make your first cup of coffee of the morning. The all-new floors and shiny cabinet doors twinkle, just a little, when the sun hits them. You have found your travel sized happy place and the peace you came for.

Guest favourite

Flat in Christiansted

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Buck Island View Studio Apartment

Studio apartment with a garden patio having a great view of the Caribbean and Buck Island. Located in the lovely neighborhood of Estate Green Cay - a 20 minute drive east of Christiansted. The path to Prune Bay beach is only a 3 minute walk away from apartment. There is also access (via foot or auto) to two other adjacent beachs: Cheney Bay and Coakley Bay The area is also great for jogging and strolling on quiet roads.

Guest favourite

Guest house in Christiansted

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

St. Croix Ocean Vista Honeymoon Cottage - Beach

1B/1B oceanfront cottage with a full kitchen sits in a gated community on St. Croix's north shore. Featured on HGTV's House Hunters International. 50 steps to the beach. Incredible sun and moon rises over the water. The cottage has battery backup so you will not be bothered by the numerous island power outages. The neighborhood borders the National Park near Salt River Bay. This is a non-smoking property.

Guest favourite

Flat in Christiansted

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

"Cozy Rooster" Artsy Studio Downtown Christiansted

Steeped in history, this residence is situated in the Historic Downtown Christiansted neighborhood, spotlighted in "Henry Morton: St. Croix, St. Thomas, St. John: Danish West Indian sketchbook and diary 1843-44." Moreover, the property holds a connection to the 1950s when the great-grandmother of the current owner called it home.